In the Midst of Sorrow

Each Jew must develop some personal perspective on the horrors of Nazi Germany. Different conclusions have been drawn, and they are reflected in the literature of post-Holocaust Western Jewry. Rather than generalize about various responses, I would like to deal with just one—that of the poet Jacob Glatstein.


Jacob Glatstein came to the United States from Lublin, Poland, in 1914. He weathered the Second World War in this country, while Lublin became the site of a large concentration camp. Glatstein had a deep love for his people and the culture of Eastern European Jewry. As the tragedy of the Holocaust became known, he eulogized a lost world—the world of the shtetl, the Yiddish language, and, in his view, the Jewish God.

In a stark poem entitled, Without Jews," he states, "Without Jews there is no Jewish God." God has "…burned in every Jewish face…glowed in every Jewish eye…" But after the slaughter of the Holocaust, who will remain to remember God? His thoughts move onto an inexorable and horrifying conclusion:

"The night is endless when a race is dead.
Earth and heaven are wiped bare.
The light is fading in your shabby tent.
The Jewish hour is guttering.
Jewish God!
You are almost gone."

Glatstein pronounces that a God who would allow six million people to die is either ineffectual or no God at all. And unfortunately his beliefs are shared by many.

The problem of how an all-knowing, all-powerful God could allow suffering in the world He created has been wrangled with by philosophers and theologians for centuries. But let's look for a moment at the reaction another Jewish man had to a similar tragedy that took place centuries earlier.


I'm speaking of the prophet Jeremiah, who lived in Judah before and during the Babylonian Captivity. He was witness to the sacking of the Temple, the most holy place in the land of Israel, and he saw his people driven from their land. In reading his Lamentations, we can feel the pain he felt as he watched Jerusalem being destroyed, as he saw children die of hunger:

"My eyes fail because of tears' my spirit is greatly troubled; my heart is poured out on the earth, because of the destruction of the daughter of my people..."

Lamentations 2:11

Jeremiah reflects a potpourri of emotions as he looks on Jerusalem. He goes from describing God's motives and his people's sins to questioning and imploring God. But in the midst of his sorrow, Jeremiah can still praise Him. There is a clear distinction between Jeremiah's reaction and that of Jacob Glatstein. Even though the prophet doesn't understand all that God has done, his every word takes into consideration the fact that an all-powerful, all-knowing and, yes, merciful God is in control of the situation.

"For the Lord will not reject forever' for if He causes grief, then He will have compassion according to His abundant lovingkindness. For He does not afflict willingly, or grieve the sons of men."

Lamentations 3:31-33

Such faith in God in the midst of personal and national suffering is not unique to Jeremiah. Imagine how Moses felt as he toiled to lead the Jewish people on a seemingly endless journey out of Egypt, yet his faith remained. They were thankless and faithless but he bore with a whole generation.


And let us remember for a moment another Jewish man-the man Jesus of Nazareth. For those who know Him, both as God and man, it's always important that we remember that all the pain and suffering He endured was felt more intensely than it wouId have been felt by any other man. Death by crucifixion was an agonizing and humiliating way to die. Yet, so much greater pain did He feel, for He was God and could have called for a legion of angels to rescue Him. Instead, He chose to die, to suffer, that all might have spiritual life. The unfortunate victims of the Holocaust could not choose to continue their physical lives. But all men can choose spiritual life for an eternity because of God's sacrifice on the cross.

Add comment

  • If your comment does not pertain to this specific article/blog please click here to send us a message. Comments not related to this article will not be posted.
  • We reserve the right to delete vulgar, racist, or hateful content, as well as inappropriate and off-topic posts.
  • Comments including links will not be published.
  • Multiple comments posted in a row will not be accepted.
  • Comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.




Im Glad That Certain Jews Belive In Jesus. I Love Your Article But If You Read Further Into The Bible You Will See That Jesus Is Not God. He Refers Him Self As The Son Of The Father. When Jesus Died He Cried Out To Jehovah. Now If He Was God Why Would He Cry Out To His Father?

john a. powell

Geesis tells us of the triune God as well as the new testament....

Lee Whitman Raymond

I knew Jacob Glatstein and he was a poet of great complexity. Your small quote and the conclusion you draw from it are terribly misleading. He would be enraged and devastated to see himself represented this way on your website.


I'd like to mention a couple more ways that Jesus suffered. 1. Bearing the sins of the world. How must One Who is Holy have felt when the sins of the whole world were put on Him??! 2. And the Father must have hid His face from Him because Jesus cried out: "My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?!!" I'd also like to reply to Kevin. Kevin, what Bible are you reading? The Bible makes clear that Jesus is God. John 1:1 says: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." A few verses down, verse 14 identifies Who the Word is. "And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us..." And here's another. Colossians 2:9 "For in Him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily." And there's plenty of others. Please read a real translation!
Issues Email Signup
Get Issues Magazine in your inbox. Sign up below!

Are you Jewish?

Do you believe in Jesus?

Issues Editions